Search Results for: violence

Deeds’ Stabbing and Suicide Expose Bed Shortage But Will Anyone Care Tomorrow?

The stabbing of Virginia state senator Creigh Deeds by his son, Austin, who later killed himself, ignited national headlines this week.  Early reports said “Gus” Deeds was released from a mental health center untreated because there were no crisis care beds available. Officials later blamed a Virginia rule that says the state must either hospitalize or discharge individuals within six hours after picking them up for observation. After he was freed, Gus attacked his father and then  turned a rifle on himself.

I was overwhelmed with calls from reporters because I had written an editorial in 2010 for The Washington Post about how Virginia was backsliding on its promises to improve mental health services after the Virginia Tech massacre. The Post tweeted links to it shortly after the Deeds’ tragedy. It also reminded readers about another Op Ed that I’d penned that described how Virginia hospitals were “streeting” patients — turning them away from emergency rooms — because there were no beds available. That revelation had come from a damning report by VA Inspector General G. Douglas Bevelacqua who has been a lone and relentless voice in Virginia when it comes to spotlighting holes in our state’s system.

Click to continue…

Bazelon Protests 60 Minutes, Attacks Fuller Torrey, While Dr. Sederer Offers His View on Forced Commitments

 60minutes

The Bazelon Center for Mental Health law  has launched a letter writing campaign  in an attempt to get 60 Minutes to do another segment about mental illness to balance what it claims was the biased viewpoint  presented in a segment called: “Untreated Mental Illness: An Imminent Danger?”   That program aired September 29th, shortly after the Navy Yard shootings, and focused  on schizophrenia and violence. Much of the broadcast was devoted to an interview between Correspondent Steve Kroft and Dr. E. Fuller Torrey, who founded the Treatment Advocacy Center. The show ended with Dr. Torrey saying:

We have a grand experiment: what happens when you don’t treat people. But then you’re going to have to accept 10 percent of homicides being killed by untreated, mentally ill people. You’re going to have to accept Tucson and Aurora. You’re going to have to accept Cho at Virginia Tech. These are the consequences, when we allow people who need to be treated to go untreated. And, if you are willing to do that, then that’s fine. But I’m not willing to do that. 

In its letter of complaint,  which was signed by some 36 other groups, Bazelon wrote:

“Imminent Danger” portrays individuals diagnosed with schizophrenia as people with
hopeless futures whose primary life options are hospitalization, homelessness, or incarceration.
The segment provides no indication that individuals with schizophrenia can and do live fulfilling
lives, start their own families, work, live independently, and participate fully in their
communities. Instead, such individuals are painted as consigned to a life of misery and as
ticking time bombs with the potential to become violent at any time. 

 The segment perpetuates false assumptions that there is a significant link between mental
health conditions and violence. Indeed, the point of the segment seems to be that mass shootings
would be preventable if it were easier to hospitalize individuals with psychiatric disabilities.

Click to continue…

My Birthday Reminds Me To Smell The Roses

firstdayofschool I turned sixty-two last Thursday and my wife, Patti, hosted a family party on Sunday.  When you have a blended family of seven, there’s always someone having a birthday but this one was different for me. I can’t say that I am going through a mid-life crisis because I already have done that, several times.  I am now old enough to collect Social Security so I have to acknowledge that I have walked over the  middle age line .

The first week of September is always a time of taking stock for me. Patti’s first husband, Steve, died on September 2nd  when he and Patti were in their thirties. Her sister, Joanne, died recently from cancer and would have celebrated her 50th birthday on Sept. 4th. Whenever I complain about getting older, Patti reminds me that Steve and Joanne didn’t celebrate as many birthdays as I have.  Patti has no patience for self-pity.

Click to continue…

From My Files Friday: Who Is To Blame For This Death?

homeless

FROM MY FILES FRIDAY:  I first published this blog in December 2010, yet the question that it poses  is just as haunting today.

WHO IS TO BLAME FOR THIS DEATH? 

The residents of Morrisville, Pa., got an intimate look this holiday season at our troubled mental health care system. Paulette Wilkie, a homeless woman with a long history of schizophrenia, was found dead from exposure. The 56 year-old woman’s   body was discovered last week behind Ben’s Deli, a sandwich shop that she frequented.

Temperatures the night before had dropped into the mid 20s. But that was not cold enough to trigger the county’s emergency homeless plan. Temperatures must sink to 20 degrees or below for two consecutive days before teams can be dispatched to try to  persuade homeless persons to come indoors.

Reporter Ben Finley, writing in the Bucks County Courier Timesnoted that people who knew Wilkie said she likely would not have gone into a shelter anyway. The owner of Ben’s Deli said Wilkie refused help from people concerned about her safety and health.Click to continue…

Is The Federal Government Destroying Our Mental Health Care System? Dr. Torrey Fires Another Broadside

Love him or hate him, Dr. E. Fuller Torrey continues to be a prolific and powerful voice in mental health.  In an article published yesterday in The National Review, the soon to be seventy-six year old psychiatrist joined with his protege, D. J. Jaffe, in attacking SAMHSA and in questioning the White House’s current campaign to reform our mental health system. torrey

Even though Torrey has contracted Parkinson disease, he has authored yet another book.  AMERICAN PSYCHOSIS: How the Federal Government Destroyed the Mental Illness Treatment System will be published in October, which is not only mental health awareness month, but also marks the 50th anniversary of the signing of the federal Community Mental Health Act.

Torrey begins his book by explaining why President John F. Kennedy made mental health a priority.  According to advance publicity for Torrey’s book, the impetus came from within his own family.

 Though he never publicly acknowledged it, the program was a tribute to Kennedy’s sister Rosemary, who was born mildly retarded and developed a schizophrenia-like illness. Terrified she’d become pregnant, Joseph Kennedy arranged for his daughter to receive a lobotomy, which was a disaster and left her severely retarded.

In a blurb for the book,  Jeffrey A. Lieberman, MD, President Elect, American Psychiatric Association and a controversial figure in his own right, writes: “Torrey is the Dorthea Dix of our time.”
Click to continue…

Do We Worry Too Much About Stigma?

stand-up-to-stigma1

I recently published blogs criticizing Dr. Phil, Dr. Oz and Brian Williams for either saying or presenting programs that marginalized and belittled persons with mental illnesses. Those blogs drew a record number of readers to this website — more than 17,000.  Obviously, fighting stigma is something, about which, many of us care.

Should we? Or are we wasting our time?

Before I chastised Dr. Phil, Dr. Oz and Brian Williams, the president and CEO of the National Council For Behavioral Health, Linda Rosenberg, wrote a column entitled: Is Mental Health Stigma Overrated? I’m a big fan of Linda’s, so much so, that I helped recruit her when the Corporation for Supportive Housing was searching for a new board member. Linda is a dynamic and innovative leader who works tirelessly to improve our mental health care system.

Click to continue…